The Toolkit for Online Communities
18814 Community Members, 0 members online, 1835 visitors today
Log In Register
OpenACS Home : Forums : OpenACS Q&A : Proposal for election process : One Message

Forum OpenACS Q&A: added approval voting to TIP

Posted by Joel Aufrecht on
I have added approval voting to the TIP as an option for the OCT members to select when approving the TIP.
Posted by Joel Aufrecht on
Note also: "While AV is a strikingly simple election reform for finding consensus choices in single-winner elections, in elections with more than one winner -- such as for a council or a legislature -- AV would not be desirable if the goal is to mirror a diversity of views, especially of minorities; for this purpose, other voting systems should be considered." (from http://alum.mit.edu/ne/whatmatters/200211/).
I don't think there's an obvious right answer, and I'm no longer worried, if I ever was, about getting this part exactly right.  I'm more interested in having high participation, a simple and comprehensible result, and an active new OCT.  Tom, I think these your points are very good and we should keep working on the issues and seeing what works.
Posted by Tom Jackson on

Joel, I think that is the impression I got. It is simple, mostly directed at getting centrist representation. It isn't really geared for including minority voices in an at large multi winner race.

Probably the simplist way to get half way there is to replace all members at the same time. This also may not be necessary for the following reason: our community is not very large. There are also organizational limits, which otherwise might lead to some kind of ballot box stuffing.

I'm still not conviced that having an election every six months is worth the extra effort. In the end everyone will serve one year terms, but we will have to expend half the effort. Working relationships will need to be adjusted every six months as new members join and have to be 'educated'. But again, this is a small community. Probably anyone elected will already have working relationships with the other members.